The curriculum of The Good Shepherd Academy is aligned The Catechesis of the Good Shepherd religion program. The Good Shepherd Academy utilizes the Memoria Press curriculum for literature, language arts, social studies, geography and Latin. The Statement of Purpose section of this website provides further description of the curriculum.

At all grade levels The Good Shepherd Academy puts more emphasis than in current times is typical on memorization and recitation of content. In later grades, formation includes the study of logic, formal argumentation, and Socratic dialogue. This enables students to develop skills in rhetoric and rational debate.